3 min readCurating a collection of antique decor has become something of a rite of passage for design enthusiasts, particularly as homeowners move away from cookie-cutter interiors in favor of spaces that feel personal, layered, and full of character. The rise of maximalism and collected-over-time aesthetics has only fueled the appeal of antique shopping, turning flea markets, estate sales, and vintage boutiques into treasure troves for those seeking one-of-a-kind finds.
Part of the allure lies in the thrill of the hunt. There’s a unique satisfaction that comes from uncovering an unexpected gem. Still, experienced designers caution that age alone doesn’t guarantee style. While antiques can add a lot to a space, not every find deserves a place in your home. Some pieces can unintentionally cheapen your interiors, especially when they don’t align with the overall design style.
Ultimately, decorating with antiques requires a balance of sentiment, function, and aesthetics. A discerning eye can make the difference between a thoughtfully curated space and one that feels stuck in the past. Ahead, designers share six “uncool” antiques they believe are best left on store shelves—unless, of course, you truly love them and can’t resist bringing them home.
Novelty Teacups
Unless a specific teacup design really speaks to your aesthetic, interior designer Susan Petrie says to think twice before purchasing. Without intentional curation, things can start to veer into “granny’s hoarding closet” territory. Her advice? “If you love vintage china, commit to one pattern and display it intentionally. You can also display just one beautiful plate on its own to make a strong statement.” Otherwise, stick to timeless white or stoneware ceramics.
Victorian-Style Lamps
The late 1800s are synonymous with over-the-top design details, such as flourishes, tufted upholstery, stained glass, and carved woodwork. Some of it can work, but curation requires a careful eye, since these pieces can quickly look out of place in most contemporary or modern homes. “The scale tends to be too low, and the detail too sweet, specifically with lamps," says designer Stephanie Hunt, who recommends looking for lamps from the 1950s, 1960s, and even 1970s instead.
Some Midcentury Seating
The appeal of midcentury modern furniture is its inherent timelessness. However, seating is a category from this era that’s a bit hit-or-miss. “I love pretty much everything mid-century, but be careful of the small scale and seat heights when you’re shopping for chairs, sofas, and the like,” advises Hunt. “They were much smaller than today’s dimensions and much lower. Adding them into current-day layouts and furnishings doesn’t always work.”
Farmhouse Signs
Those who live on the lake or farm can get a pass on this one if it’s country kitsch you’re after, but otherwise it’s best to leave farmhouse or marquee signs where you found them. “They might say things like ‘Lakehouse' or ‘Eat.’ They remind me of a TGI Friday's, and come off as kitschy or campy,” says Lina Galvao, founder ofCurated Nest Interiors. “Only use these if they are truly unique and serve as a conversation starter. I would opt for a real piece of art or a collected item instead.”
Ornately Carved Furniture
Similarly, Hunt says that carved case goods or upholstered pieces on a frame can read very “great grandmother.” These are often from the Victorian era (or inspired by it), but she adds that some French pieces (e.g., Louis XV, Rococo) also don’t work as well in today’s homes.
Instead, look for larger or more minimally carved pieces. “Spanish and Portuguese carved pieces tend to work well with either clean-lined upholstered profiles or other pieces,” she says. “Also steer toward Louis XVI and Gustavian pieces as the lines are cleaner. You’re less likely to tire of those pieces in the long term.”
Plates with Inspirational Quotes
Before the “live, laugh, love” decorating era came the “bless this home” era, and many iterations existed even before then. Petrie warns that decorative plates with inspirational quotes often read as a bit cliché, and they’re more dated than darling.
“We don't need to be reminded of the barrage of quotes we see online daily, and what can be communicated in person is an earnest way that comes across in a more meaningful way,” she says. “Instead, hang a single ceramic platter with a beautiful glaze or hand-painted details.”
